
Same workplace. Same rules. Nearly identical conduct. But two very different outcomes. Why does one employee get a second chance while another gets disciplined—or fired? When the rules seem to change depending on who’s involved, the disparity may reveal more than inconsistent management. It may expose a double standard with serious legal consequences.
In employment-discrimination cases, the difference between how employees are treated can tell a revealing story about an employer’s motives. But when does unequal treatment become evidence of unlawful discrimination? Here’s my point of view.
IMPORTANT: All hyperlinks in this article with an asterisk (*) will take the reader away from this website to either our Williams Law Group Blog*, an official governmental website, or a well-recognized organization. This article is for informational purposes only and is based upon my point of view. Due to the rapidly changing nature of the law, we make no warranty or guarantee concerning the accuracy or reliability of the content in this article. No content on this site, regardless of date, should ever be used as a substitute for direct legal advice from your attorney. Please review our Disclaimer|Terms of Use|Privacy Policy before proceeding.
Advertisement
Double Standard: When the Rules Change Depending on Who You Are
What Is a Double Standard?
A double standard occurs when different rules, expectations, or standards are applied to people who are similarly situated, without a legitimate reason for the difference. In everyday terms, it means holding one person accountable for something while excusing another person for substantially the same conduct.
Consider two employees who arrive late to work under comparable circumstances. One receives a written warning, while the other faces no consequences. If the employer cannot identify a legitimate reason for treating the employees differently, the inconsistent enforcement may suggest that something other than the workplace rule influenced the decision.
A double standard is not necessarily a formal logical fallacy. Rather, it describes inconsistent treatment that can expose flawed reasoning, unfairness, or potentially discriminatory decision-making.
video Example: Double Standard
How Double Standards Appear in Employment Discrimination
In the workplace, double standards can arise in hiring, promotions, discipline, performance evaluations, compensation, and termination decisions.
Consider a hypothetical situation involving two employees who make similar mistakes. One employee is given an opportunity to correct the problem, while the other is disciplined or terminated. If the employees are similarly situated and the difference in treatment cannot be adequately explained, the disparity may be evidence of discrimination.
For Washington employment-discrimination trial attorneys, these inconsistencies can be particularly important. An employer may claim that an employee was terminated for violating a workplace policy. But if employees outside the plaintiff‘s protected class committed comparable violations without receiving similar discipline, the employer’s explanation deserves closer examination.
The important question is not simply whether two employees were treated differently. It is whether the differences in treatment can be explained by legitimate circumstances or whether the evidence supports an inference of unlawful discrimination.
The Connection to Washington Law
Washington’s Law Against Discrimination (WLAD), chapter 49.60* RCW, prohibits specified discriminatory employment practices. In disparate-treatment cases, an employer violates the law when it treats an employee less favorably because of a protected characteristic.
In Blackburn v. State*, 186 Wn.2d 250 (2016), the Washington Supreme Court* addressed disparate treatment under the WLAD and explained that it involves treating some people less favorably than others because of a protected characteristic.
Evidence that similarly situated employees outside the plaintiff‘s protected class received more favorable treatment can help establish an inference of discrimination. Relevant considerations may include whether employees had comparable responsibilities, engaged in similar conduct, were subject to the same workplace rules, and were evaluated by the same decision-maker.
However, different treatment does not automatically establish discrimination. Employers may have legitimate reasons for treating employees differently. The surrounding circumstances and the evidence supporting the employer’s explanation matter.
Turning the Double Standard into an Advocacy Tool
Recognizing potential double standards can help employment-discrimination attorneys identify important evidence and develop effective trial strategies.
Plaintiff‘s attorneys should examine whether workplace rules were consistently applied and whether employees outside the plaintiff‘s protected class received more favorable treatment under comparable circumstances. Defense attorneys should be prepared to explain legitimate differences between employees and the reasons for different employment decisions.
Both sides should look beyond the employer’s written policies and examine how those policies were actually enforced. A workplace rule may appear neutral on paper but be applied inconsistently in practice.
Ultimately, the question is whether the evidence reveals legitimate distinctions between employees or an unjustified difference in treatment connected to a protected characteristic.
Closing Argument
A workplace rule means little if it is enforced against some employees but ignored for others without a legitimate explanation. Consistency matters, not simply because employees expect fair treatment, but because unequal enforcement can reveal discriminatory decision-making.
For Washington employment-discrimination trial attorneys, identifying a double standard can be an important step in uncovering the reasons behind an employer’s actions. The strongest arguments are built not merely on pointing out that two employees were treated differently, but on demonstrating why the difference matters and what it reveals about the employer’s decision.
When the rules change depending on who you are, the question is no longer just whether the rules were followed. It is why they were applied differently in the first place.
Read Our Related Articles
» How Lawyers Utilize Deductive and Inductive Reasoning
» Law & Logic: Affirming the Consequent
» Law & Logic: Appeal to Emotion
» Law & Logic: Argument from Fallacy or Bad Reasons Fallacy
» Law & Logic: Argument from Incredulity
» Law & Logic: Argumentum Ad Antiquitam (Appeal to Tradition)
» Law & Logic: Argumentum Ad Baculum (Appeal to Force)
» Law & Logic: Argumentum Ad Ignorantium (Appeal to Ignorance)
» Law & Logic: Argumentum Ad Nauseam
» Law & Logic: Argumentum Ad Populum
» Law & Logic: Argumentum Ad Vercundiam (Appeal to Authority)
» Law & Logic: Complex Question (False Dilemma)
» Law & Logic: Confirmation Bias & Sunk Cost Fallacy
» Law & Logic: Conjunction Fallacy
» Law & Logic: Cum Hoc Ergo Propter Hoc (False Cause)
» Law & Logic: Fallacy of the Inverse (Denying the Antecedent)
» Law & Logic: Halo Effect and Gambler’s Fallacy
» Law & Logic: Hasty Generalization
» Law & Logic: Ignoratio Elenchi (Irrelevant Conclusion)
» Law & Logic: Ipse Dixit Fallacy or “It Simply Is”
» Law & Logic: Petitio Principii (Circular Reasoning)
» Law & Logic: Proper Reasoning (Valid Logic)
» Law & Logic: Single Cause Fallacy (Complex Cause)
» Law & Logic: The False Compromise
» Law & Logic: The Straw Man Fallacy
LEARN MORE
If you would like to learn more, then consider contacting an experienced employment attorney to discuss your case. This article is not offered as legal advice and will not establish an attorney-client relationship with Law Office of Gregory A. Williams or the author of this article; please refer to our Disclaimer | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy for more information.
–gw

